A week ago we stood in a moment of silence to remember the 6 million Jews who vanished in the ovens and mass graves of Hitler’s Europe. For 24 hours we once again heard the stories of atrocities, of the heroics of bravery and small kindnesses in the face of unimaginable degradation and physical hardship. We saw survivors speaking about the richness of the extended family which was extinguished so unspeakably and so completely.
One short week later we again stood in a moment of silence to remember Jewish deaths and have now spent almost 24 hours hearing stories of those killed once again for being Jews. The atrocities of bombing buses, shooting women and children, bombing Jews conducting a seder on Passover, and, of course, the horrific butchery of five members of the Fogel family just weeks ago in the community of Itamar.
Nowhere in the world can Holocaust Remembrance Day and Memorial Day for Fallen Soldiers and Victims of Terror be as poignant as in Israel. Nowhere in the world is the Jewish Family so concentrated and interconnected as in Israel.
From the depths of despair, at the mercy of the most uneducated, the simplest of peasants nurtured with hatred engendered by ignorance, starved, killed on the slightest whim, deprived of the most basic need – that of protecting our children- we rose, literally from the ashes, in only one generation to a state of our own where we can never again be helpless to protect our families.
The week beginning with Holocaust Remembrance Day and culminating in Israel Independence Day is a roller coaster of emotions for the entire nation. We – that noisy, rowdy bunch – Israelis – actually stop and collectively, as one, stand silently in awareness of our history.
I read about Anne Frank and many other books on the Holocaust when I was in my early teens. I watched Holocaust movies and heard Holocaust stories. It was a phase, like loving horses, and then it was over. I rarely picked up another Holocaust book afterwards.
I made aliya to Israel as an adventure and, partially, to try to make a difference in a new country. I was neither fervently religious nor much of a Zionist – though a little bit of both.
I loved living in America and had it pretty good there. Fortunate enough to be born into a family with enough money (not under a bridge in Bombay, as I tell my children when they complain). I had the luxury of rebelling against the establishment and protesting the government without getting mowed down by tanks, still managing to receive multiple university degrees.
I didn’t feel discriminated against. I rarely felt uncomfortable as a Jew.
And yet, for the past 32 years I’ve lived in a country steeped in the emotions of Holocaust survivors and their children. I’ve never passed through a Holocaust Remembrance Day emotionally unscathed.
I’ve lived in a country where Jews don military garb (sloppy but military nevertheless), sacrificing three years of their young lives when most American kids are off exploring campus life. In a country where hi-tech workers, lawyers and accountants leave their jobs for a month every year to train, guard and sometimes fight so that the rest of us can live a somewhat normal life in this crazy, tiny country of ours.
I’ve never passed through the Memorial Day for Fallen Soldiers and Victims of Terror without that schizophrenic sadness and immeasurable pride and gratitude.
Every year I go to a ceremony about 10 minutes from my house in a beautiful valley surrounded by heights covered with olive trees and scrub brush and gorgeous rock formations where 10 reserve duty soldiers were ambushed and killed. It’s a ceremony for all those in my region who died for our country’s continued existence. At the end, the mayor of our region reads the list of those people. I knew many of them. I remember some of them as children and some as colleagues and neighbors.
This year, for some reason, I thought alot about Hana, a friend who came from Russia, with a frizzy reddish afro, an inexhaustibly happy spirit, who was learning flamenco when she was blown up on a bus in Jerusalem.
It’s a long list.
This year Udi Fogel’s mother spoke through her tears about her son and her grandchildren who were butchered in their sleep. Shlomo Riachi openly wept as he said kaddish. I remember his son, Kfir, as a smiling, happy child who grew into the 15 year old shot many years ago as he played basketball with his friends.
I cried, too. I do every year.
Yesterday I went to the brit (circumcision) of my best friend’s grandson. I’ve known the father of the baby, Ehud, since he wasn’t much more than a baby himself. He spoke about how his new baby, Nir, was born on Holocaust Remembrance Day and his brit was on the eve of Memorial Day for Fallen Soldiers and Victims of Terror.
He spoke about the vast difference – one being the very depths of Galut (the Diaspora) and the other commemorating the heights of the beginning of the Geula (Redemption).
He spoke about how the brit is a contract between Jews and God which, like any legal contract, binds both sides. He said that he often wonders why his parents’ generation was blessed with the creation of the State of Israel when so many great people came before them and were not so blessed. Somehow during the week between Nir’s birth on Holocaust Day and his entering into the brit with God on Memorial Day for Fallen Soldiers and Victims of Terror, it started to make sense to him.
The brit or contract with God challenges both parties. It is only with great effort that we earned the beginning of the Geula in the creation of the Jewish State. That great effort is what binds God to the Geula.
The ultimate “what goes around, comes around”.
In two hours Memorial Day will be over for another year. We’ll begin Israeli Independence Day. We’ll sing and watch our children perform. We’ll ooh and aah at another great fireworks show in the skies over Ofra.
And, finally, before heading home, we’ll sing the Israeli National Anthem, HaTikva (The Hope) – maybe the only national anthem which sounds a bit like a funeral dirge in parts – and I’ll get a lump in my throat again, for the thousandth time, and feel a pride and comfort that no international community, world media, J Street (or L, M, N, O, P Street) can stamp out.
Thank you, Kfir, Hana, Udi, Gabriel. Thank you Irit, Miri, Erez, Noa. Thank you Aryeh, Asaf, Ofra, Sarah. Thank you, thank you to the 20,000 plus Jews who have died to strengthen the State of Israel for me to live in today.
Wow! I’ve become a Zionist!

